Sweet Paprika Substitute, You Must Know

Kaiya Everly

Updated on:

sweet paprika substitute

Spices are one of the most heavily used ingredients in dishes. Every kitchen cabinet has paprika species that don’t get much attention. Today, let’s explore everything about sweet paprika and sweet paprika substitute.

What Is Sweet Paprika?

Sweet paprika is a condiment made by using ground dry red peppers. For this spice, mostly sweet, mild, bright red peppers are used. The taste of sweet paprika is fruity, bitter, tangy, and sweet instead of spicy!

Also Read : Paprika: What Is It & Its Different Types To Know

Substitutes For Sweet Paprika

You can consider the following options and use them as substitutes for sweet paprika.

  1. Chili Powder

One of the best substitutes for sweet paprika is chili powder. This powder is made by blending spices like cumin, garlic powder, oregano, and chili peppers. 

  1. Cayenne Pepper

Compared to sweet paprika, cayenne pepper is slightly stronger in flavor. To get a closer flavor to sweet paprika, you can add a bit of sugar to tone down the heat.

  1. Chipotle Chili Powder

If you don’t have chili powder or cayenne pepper, you can opt for chipotle chili powder. It will give you the same dash of color as sweet paprika. Try adding sugar to tone down the heat.

  1. Tomato Powder

You can replace sweet paprika with tomato powder which is made by using dried, ground tomatoes. It will give you identical flavors but different than paprika’s earthy notes. You can even use tomato juice as a replacement for sweet paprika.

  1. Ancho Chili Powder

In your pantry, search for ancho chili powder if you don’t have sweet paprika. This particular condiment adds a bit of smokiness and sweet flavor to your dish. 

  1. Aleppo Pepper Powder

Aleppo pepper powder is an aromatic spice that has a sweet, tangy flavor with medium heat like Hungarian paprika. This spice acts as a direct replacement for sweet paprika as you get a similar color and flavor.

  1. Guajillo Chili Powder

This condiment is known for its vibrant red color and sweetness like a berry. Use this spice in place of sweet paprika to add a little heat and a sweet undertone to your dish.

  1. Red Bell Peppers

You can instantly make paprika powder at home by using red bell peppers. Dry some red bell peppers in an oven or dehydrator and grind them into fine powder. otherwise, you can chop fresh bell pepper, cook it, and then add it to your dish.

  1. Red Chilli Flakes

Red chili flakes is another quick and easy substitute for sweet paprika! Compared to sweet paprika, red chili flakes are coarser and chunkier. But you will get closer to flavor and color.

  1. Black Peppercorn

Try to use freshly ground black peppercorns instead of sweet paprika. This will add a bit of heat and smoky flavor to your dish. But you won’t get the same color of sweet paprika. 

  1. Hot Sauce

Surprisingly, you can use hot sauce in place of sweet paprika. Hot sauce will give you a smokey, sweet flavor with slight heat. You can add a bit of vinegar to get the tangy flavor. 

  1. Other Spices

Consider these spices if you don’t have any of the above-mentioned options in your kitchen cabinet.

  • Use aromatic spices like nutmeg, cinnamon, or cloves.
  • Try mixing different spices like mace, mustard, garlic powder, or cumin.
  • Ground ginger or black pepper powder.

Also Read : Hungarian Paprika: What Is It & Where To Buy

Where To Buy Sweet Paprika Substitutes

You can get your hands on sweet paprika substitutes in well-stocked grocery stores and big supermarkets. Otherwise, you can easily find them on online websites like Amazon.

Tips To Consider While Using Sweet Paprika Substitutes

It’s important to use these substitutes with caution as you ruin dishes. Here are some quick tips you must consider while using sweet paprika substitutes.

  1. Just make sure you start with a smaller quantity and then add accordingly.
  2. Use substitutes according to the type of your dish.
  3. Understand the flavors of your substitute as they can affect the taste of your dish.
  4. Try to get the right balance so that the flavors don’t control other ingredients.


I hope you had fun learning about the best sweet paprika substitute. This condiment is quite popular and used as a key ingredient in Hungarian dishes. Do not get confused between paprika vs sweet paprika as both look alike. Thus, you can play with different flavors by using these substitutes.


What To Use If You Run Out Of Sweet Paprika?

You can use chili powder or cayenne powder if you run out of sweet paprika.

Are There Any Benefits Of Sweet Paprika?

Sweet paprika helps to maintain healthy vision, prevent chronic disease, and promote heart health.

What To Make With Paprika?

Using paprika you can easily make traditional Hungarian dishes like goulash, and paprikash. You can even directly rub the spice on meats.

Where Was Sweet Paprika First Cultivated?

Sweet paprika was first cultivated in Central America.